MEMO: Declining Facebook engagement on articles and link posts


Two recent NewsWhip reports highlighted that “engagements [on Facebook] dropped across the board for the top publishers” in September. The CAP Action Analytics team looked into this more closely and confirmed a decrease in average engagement on link posts across a wide array of Facebook pages between July and September. While this appears to affect both conservative and progressive pages alike, conservative pages rely more heavily on link posts for their engagement, making this a trend to watch more closely going forward.

These observed changes occur throughout a period in which Facebook has been responding to heavy scrutiny about the types of content it promotes. In mid-August, Facebook released its first “Widely Viewed Content Report” to counteract the ideas that right-wing propaganda dominates its site — although an earlier, shelved version of that report painted a conflicting picture. Then, on August 31, Facebook announced that tests to reduce political content in news feeds were being expanded internationally. These events do not directly explain the observed changes in engagement we see in this report, but are helpful context to accompany these findings.

Using data from the social listening tool NewsWhip, CAP Action built a database of Facebook posts from a set of 500+ politically-oriented progressive and conservative pages between July 1 and September 20, 2021. The September 20th cutoff is to avoid some data inconsistencies in our exports that were introduced in late September. This dataset consists of approximately 162,000 Facebook posts, including 94,000 link posts. We define engagements as a sum of shares, comments, likes, and other reactions — not including link clicks, post clicks, or views.

In accordance with the Newswhip report, we found that from July to September, average post engagement by month:

This is despite the relatively consistent volume of posts (see below).

Note that August 2021 was a high-water mark in engagements overall for conservative pages, largely due to the Afghanistan withdrawal. For that reason, we consider July to be a more accurate baseline from which to measure changes.

When we break this data out into link posts vs. non-link posts, we see a clearer trend:

The following two charts show average engagements per post on conservative and progressive pages tracked in our database for link posts (above) and all other posts (below):

Notice that the gap in average engagements between progressive and conservative pages is higher for link posts than it is for other formats. If engagements with link posts continue to decrease across the board, that could have the effect of narrowing the overall engagement gap between conservative and progressive pages.

Conservative pages averaged roughly 5,500 engagements per link post in July, which went down to 4,500 in September. Meanwhile, non-link posts showed no decrease. For progressives, we see a slight decrease in engagement for both link and non-link posts. See the full monthly breakout in the Appendix.

We then looked closer to see how that July-September decrease broke out across the top 25 sites in our database.

Zooming Out
While we do not have access to a more granular, post-level dataset going back to the start of 2021 or previous years, we can validate these top-level findings in NewsWhip Analytics with specific domains. In this case, we pulled aggregate Facebook engagements for articles published by four sites (The Daily Wire, Breitbart, The New York Times, and MSNBC) for each year between 2016 and 2021, stitched the data together, and graphed the result.

The chart below is a representation of monthly engagement on articles from four of these sites shared by all public Facebook pages in the NewsWhip database — a broader set of pages than our list of progressive and conservative pages.

The year-over-year findings are significant. First, we can see that spring and summer 2020 led to a massive spike in engagements for each site — which makes sense given the onset of a global pandemic, a presidential election kicking into gear, and the largest movement of protests in U.S. history. Second, the increase in engagement for the Daily Wire (and to a lesser extent, Breitbart) in 2020 was disproportionate, far out-pacing the New York Times in engagement by June 2020 after years of lagging behind it.

Third, after the Biden administration takes office in January 2021 we see both the New York Times and Breitbart experience a sharp decrease in engagements, reflective of the return to normalcy and a “boring” presidency. MSNBC’s decline came much earlier, in fall 2020. But the Daily Wire’s engagements held staying power, continuing to rack up tens of millions of engagements a month well into 2021. Only in the last couple of months, with one drop in July and then another in September, has the Daily Wire experienced a decline towards pre-2020 levels.

Note that data on two additional domains, the Western Journal and, displayed similar trends but was omitted from this chart for readability. For an expanded version of the chart, see the appendix.

Why is this important? A significant part of conservatives’ Facebook strategy is centered around sharing links from conservative news outlets or aggregation sites.

Moreover, frequently conservative Facebook pages are stood up solely to disseminate links to one site. There are more than 40 conservative pages in our dataset where at least 70% of their Facebook posts are links to a single domain, compared to only 13 progressive pages.

We also looked at the messages being pushed within link posts with both progressive and conservative pages, and how those might be affected by these changes. We focused on two topics that have been rife with misinformation recently: the pandemic response and conflicts over vaccines, as well as the fabricated controversy over critical race theory (CRT) in school curricula being driven by conservative outlets.

How might this translate into reach, and how many people are vulnerable to misinformation? Based on our internal page data, we estimate that each engagement is roughly associated with 20 people reached on average. Extrapolating that outward for a conservative page with similar performance, a decline of 1,300 engagements means that 26,000 fewer people might be seeing CRT-related misinformation per post.



Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
CAP Action

Hard-hitting news + analysis paired with action on the issues that matter most. Working alongside @AmProg.